GETTYSBURG, Pa. — Former Gettysburg Mayor Chad-Alan Carr pleaded guilty Tuesday, Nov. 17, to three charges stemming from allegations of sexual misconduct involving minors, resolving several criminal cases that had been scheduled for trial in Adams County.
Carr entered the pleas as part of a negotiated agreement that calls for a prison sentence of nine to 23 months, followed by up to three years of probation.
The former mayor pleaded guilty to one felony count involving the depiction of child sexual abuse on a computer and two misdemeanor counts of corruption of minors.
Prosecutors agreed to withdraw several other charges, including two felony sexual assault counts, as part of the agreement.
Adams County Judge Shawn Wagner increased Carr’s bail from $100,000 to $101,000 following the hearing. Carr was taken into custody Tuesday afternoon.
A formal sentencing hearing is scheduled for Feb. 17.
Charges stem from incidents dating to 2006
The criminal proceedings involved allegations from four individuals, three of whom were minors at the time of the reported incidents.
The felony conviction relates to allegations involving a 16-year-old whom Carr met through Gettysburg Community Theatre.
According to the allegations, Carr engaged in sexually explicit online communications with the teenager between 2012 and 2013, including video interactions conducted through Skype.
Carr previously served as executive director of Gettysburg Community Theatre, a position he held beginning in 2009 before resigning in March 2026.
One corruption of minors conviction stems from an incident involving a 15-year-old theater performer in 2006 or 2007. Investigators alleged Carr sought sexually explicit photographs from the teenager.
The second corruption of minors conviction involves a 16-year-old whom Carr met through an online dating application.
A sexual assault charge associated with that incident was withdrawn under the plea agreement.
Prosecutors also withdrew a separate felony sexual assault charge involving an allegation from 2015. Carr did not plead guilty to any offense arising from that allegation.
Court rulings preceded plea agreement
The guilty pleas followed several pretrial rulings that affected how prosecutors could proceed with the cases.
In September, Wagner dismissed two felony criminal solicitation charges after determining they were barred by the applicable statute of limitations.
An October ruling also required prosecutors to pursue the four sets of allegations in separate trials rather than present them together before a single jury.
The decision followed Pennsylvania Supreme Court precedent governing the circumstances under which evidence of separate alleged offenses may be introduced in a criminal trial.
The rulings limited prosecutors’ ability to present the allegations collectively as evidence of a pattern of conduct.
The negotiated plea agreement resolved the remaining charges without the need for the scheduled trials.
Former mayor resigned earlier this year
Carr resigned as Gettysburg mayor March 5, approximately two months after beginning his first term.
His resignation preceded the public announcement of criminal charges involving alleged conduct more than a decade earlier.
Additional allegations subsequently emerged, leading to further criminal proceedings.
Carr had previously served on Gettysburg Borough Council before winning the 2025 mayoral election.
He also held a leadership position at Gettysburg Community Theatre for more than a decade.
Sentencing scheduled for February
Under the negotiated agreement, Carr faces nine to 23 months of incarceration and up to three years of probation.
He is expected to receive credit for approximately six months previously spent in custody.
The amount of additional time Carr must serve will depend on the final sentencing order, applicable credit for time served and any parole determination.
His sentencing hearing is scheduled for Feb. 17, 2027, in Adams County Court.