HAGERSTOWN, Md. – Democrat Lara Shepherd has defeated Washington County Board of Commissioners President John Barr by 335 votes, overturning an apparent Republican sweep on election night and becoming the first Democrat elected to the five-member board in 16 years.
After the initial Nov. 3 returns, Shepherd trailed Barr by 855 votes, leaving her in sixth place and Barr holding the fifth and final seat. Those election-night figures were unofficial and did not include all eligible ballots. As election officials completed the required post-election canvass of mail-in and provisional ballots, Shepherd erased the deficit and overtook the four-term Republican incumbent.
The latest tally gave Shepherd 21,202 votes to Barr’s 20,867 – a 1,190-vote reversal in their margin since election night.
End of Barr era
The outcome ends unanimous Republican control of the board, which dates to the 2010 election. Shepherd will also become the board’s only woman and its first female commissioner since 2014.
The upset carries particular significance for Barr, who served three consecutive terms from 2006 to 2018 before returning for a fourth in 2022. He led the field in votes that year and subsequently became board president.
In a written statement, Barr congratulated the incoming commissioners.
“I wish them well and trust collectively they will serve the citizens to the best of their abilities with compassion and integrity,” he said.
Barr’s defeat follows a turbulent period in which commissioners faced repeated public protests, disruptions and criticism over restrictions on public comment at their meetings.
More recently, the Barr-led board initially appeared supportive of a proposed federal ICE detention center near Williamsport, then adopted a more cautious position as public opposition mounted. Commissioners repeatedly relied on carefully worded statements about their limited authority over the federal project, frustrating residents who wanted them to take a clear stand.

How the vote count changed
With all 47 precincts reporting on election night, the five Republican candidates occupied the winning positions, and Shepherd led the Democratic field but remained outside the cutoff.
By Thursday, Nov. 12, Shepherd had moved ahead of Barr by 230 votes. Friday’s count increased her lead to 335, securing her the last available seat and dropping Barr to sixth.
The other four winners were Republicans Randy Leatherman, who led the field with 24,533 votes; Dan Young, with 24,077; Charles Burkett, with 23,542; and Jeffrey Cline, with 22,075.
The new commission will include two returning incumbents, Leatherman and Cline, and three incoming members, Shepherd, Young and Burkett. Burkett previously served on the commission and currently holds a seat on the Washington County Board of Education.
Commissioners will choose a new president and vice president after the new board takes office. The board has traditionally selected the candidate receiving the most votes as president, although that practice is not mandatory. Leatherman led this year’s field.
A different voice on the commission
Shepherd, a Hagerstown-area business leader, has emphasized communication and transparency as priorities.
“No matter what side of the table you’re on, you believe in transparency, and you believe in having good conversations with our community because it takes all of us to work together to make this county better,” she told DC News Now.
Shepherd also opposes the proposed federal immigration detention center near Williamsport, an issue that has generated controversy over immigration enforcement, wastewater capacity and demands on local infrastructure.
Her election introduces a dissenting voice into a commission that will remain Republican-controlled, four seats to one.
The road ahead
The incoming board faces several consequential decisions, including permanent regulations for data centers, funding for schools and emergency services, and whether to restore general public comment at commissioners’ business meetings.
The county imposed a 12-month moratorium on new data center applications in June while planners develop zoning regulations. Commissioners must decide whether to adopt those rules, extend the moratorium or pursue another approach before it expires in June 2027.
The new commissioners will also inherit the debate over the proposed ICE detention center, although federal authorities control the facility’s operations.